🎉 Up to 70% Off Selected Items
Shop Sale
✕
Home
Shop
Cart
Account
Account
Your Cart (0)
Mustard
Award Winners
Specialty Food
Gifts
Merch
Shop by Collection
Home
Store
Pet Toys
Pet Toys
Filters
Filter products by category, price, and more
Sort:
Latest Arrivals
Pet Toys | National Mustard Museum
NEW
Fred Howligans Toast Distract-O-Mat Lick Mat
$12.95
New
0% OFF
Quick View
NEW
Blue Q Catnip Toy - DUUUUUUDE
$11.99
New
0% OFF
Quick View
NEW
Blue Q Catnip Toy - Meet the Zoomies
$11.99
New
0% OFF
Quick View
NEW
Blue Q Catnip Toy - Check Out My Butthole
$11.99
New
0% OFF
Quick View
NEW
Blue Q Catnip Toy - Your Cat is High
$11.99
New
0% OFF
Quick View
NEW
Blue Q Catnip Toy - Asshole Cat
$11.99
New
0% OFF
Quick View
-65%
NEW
Blue Q Catnip Toy - Precious Angel Baby
$11.99
$4.20
New
65% OFF
Quick View
NEW
Blue Q Catnip Toy - Existential Kitty
$11.99
New
0% OFF
Quick View
-65%
NEW
Blue Q Catnip Toy - Talk To Your Kittens About Catnip
$11.99
$4.20
New
65% OFF
Quick View
-65%
NEW
Blue Q Catnip Toy - Never Trust Your Tail
$11.99
$4.20
New
65% OFF
Quick View
